(Updated April 2021)
While Indianapolis doesn’t have its own signature type of pizza (looking at you Chicago and New York), it is still home to some great pizza options. Across the city, you can pick from some of the most popular pizzas from different pizzerias.
Read below to find a list of the best pizza restaurants according to Google Reviews. You can not only find a list full of options ranging from high end to affordable options, but also restaurants specializing in various different types of pizza. Find your new favorite on this list today.
And remember, if you feel more comfortable staying at home and ordering food delivery, use contactless options from a third party service or order direct restaurant and get the same food with greater peace of mind. Remember to tip your food delivery courier and let's all do our best to keep each other safe!
Compare Food Delivery Fees in IndianapolisIf you're in Indianapolis searching for some other great options, click the button below and search from thousands of restaurants in your area to find the best meal with the best delivery offer.
Explore the great list below for the top choices according to locals on Google Reviews to determine where you should get your next meal. If you're craving pizza, Indianapolis has tons of amazing options. Whatever you decide, make sure you stay safe and bring protective gear to the restaurants if outdoor seating is open, or order to your home and enjoy the great meal in front of the tv, outside, or with your family.
Unfortunately over the past year or so many restaurants across the country have been forced to close. We've recently gone through this list of the best pizza restaurants in Indianapolis to make sure we have noted which of these options are still open. Unless otherwise noted, all these restaurants are open in some capacity.
Happy Eating!
Ratings and additional data pulled from Google:
MOD Pizza
Manhattan Pizzeria
Brozinni Pizzeria
King Dough
Napolese Pizzeria
Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta
Goodfellas Mass Ave
Compare Food Delivery Fees in IndianapolisRead below for more details about each of these restaurants:
MOD Pizza
8505 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States
Counter-serve chain with industrial-chic decor known for build-your-own pizza.
Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Small plates
4.7 Stars, 355 Reviews, $
Manhattan Pizzeria
6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States
Comfort food · Small plates · Quick bite
4.7 Stars, 231 Reviews, $
Brozinni Pizzeria
8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237, United States
Family-friendly pizza place features the Big Apple's signature crust & a small menu of Italian eats.
Comfort food · Quick bite · Fast service
4.7 Stars, 1,149 Reviews, $$
4919 38th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States
Informal joint featuring traditional pizza, burgers & other typical grub in a no-frills setting.
Late-night food · Comfort food · Small plates
4.6 Stars, 603 Reviews, $$
6235 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States
Relaxed Italian eatery offering thin-crust pizza with inventive topping combos such as Thai & Cajun.
Comfort food · Quick bite · Cosy
4.6 Stars, 443 Reviews, $$
5646 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, United States
Homey, family-friendly eatery for gourmet-style pizzas, sandwiches & more with beer & wine.
Late-night food · Outdoor seating · Quick bite
4.6 Stars, 2,145 Reviews, $$
811 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States
Creative thin- or thick-crust pies in a rustic old house with a patio, plus beer & wine.
Late-night food · Comfort food · Outdoor seating
4.5 Stars, 746 Reviews, $$
65 E Pearl St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Microbrews, salads, sandwiches & build-your-own pies in a family-friendly eatery with a bar & TVs.
Late-night food · Comfort food · Quick bite
4.5 Stars, 688 Reviews, $$
King Dough
452 N Highland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States
Late-night food · Comfort food · Outdoor seating
4.5 Stars, 450 Reviews, $$
Napolese Pizzeria
114 E 49th St, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States
Artisanal pizzas & Italian bites served with beer, wine & cocktails in modern surroundings.
Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Small plates
4.5 Stars, 236 Reviews, $$
Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta
3944 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States
Regional chain for pizzas & other Italian basics, plus craft beer & wine, served in casual environs.
Comfort food · Quick bite · Casual
4.5 Stars, 177 Reviews, $$
Goodfellas Mass Ave
545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Late-night food · Happy hour drinks · Comfort food
4.5 Stars, 1,193 Reviews, $
924 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States
Comfy English-themed pub specializing in beer on tap & traditional grub as well as pizza.
Late-night food · Comfort food · Small plates
4.4 Stars, 615 Reviews, $$
9 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Thin- & thick-crust pizza & subs from an Italian-born chef, plus beer & wine in a quick-serve space.
Comfort food · Quick bite · Cosy
4.4 Stars, 504 Reviews, $
5615 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208, United States
Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Quick bite
4.3 Reviews, 161 Reviews, $$
Rivers Edge, 4110 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States
Known for deep-dish pizza, this casual chain serves other classic Italian food, plus beer & wine.
Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Cosy
4.3 Stars, 1,130 Reviews, $$
As you’ll see, there are lots of great options to find the meal you’re looking for. If you don’t feel like eating out, and would rather stay at home, remember you can still get all these great meals in the comfort of your house with food delivery.
Compare Food Delivery Fees in IndianapolisWith FoodBoss, you can easily find the best food delivery option by comparing multiple food delivery services at once. Compare various delivery fees, service fees, small cart fees, and other fees as well as varying delivery estimate times. Never overpay or wait too long for food delivery ever again.
*April 2021 Update: Depending on the specific location, due to the restrictions, some restaurants may either be available only for delivery and/or carry out, while others may offer dine-in service. To be 100% sure we recommend calling ahead to the restaurant to make sure they are open and available for the type of service you're looking for.