An Introduction to Pie Guy Pizza

Pie Guy Pizza is one of the top rated pizza restaurants in St. Louis. It is a hip and unique place with hand-tossed, New York style pizza and late night offerings. On Friday and Saturday nights you can grab a slice until 3:30 AM! Or get a full pizza, along with appetizers and salads any other day of the week. Pie Guy also has a huge selection of beers to accompany your meal, and the staff is very friendly as well.Recently, Pie Guy Pizza was included in the FoodBoss Experience’s Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Louis article.

Here is a quick overview of Pie Guy Pizza from Google Reviews:

Pie Guy Pizza

4189 Manchester Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110, United States

Late-night food · Comfort food · Small plates

4.8 Stars, 117 Reviews, Price n/a

Order Pie Guy Pizza food delivery now!

Pie Guy Pizza is a casual restaurant with a simple menu of pizza classics to taste. They even offer Pie Guy pizza classics for customers to learn how to make their own! Their food is reasonably priced and they appeal to beer-lovers with their drink options.

Google reviews show 4.8 stars with almost 117 ratings. Looking to order Pie Guy Pizza already, here’s a link to find the best food delivery offer possible with FoodBoss! With FoodBoss sort by delivery options from multiple services to find the one with the lowest fees and quickest delivery times.

Yelp Reviews

Below are a few reviews from Yelp from Pie Guy Pizza. Hear from other people who have already eaten at Pie Guy Pizza to help you determine if this is your next pizza destination. Read about their experiences so you can know what to expect.

All of the reviews below were found on and you can find links to each of the reviews themselves below as well.

Review 1:

Window for pizza and snacks (including salads, garlic knots, pretzel bites, etc) that is connected to a taproom and bottle shop in The Grove. Tap room has an enormous selection of beer, and has both table and counter bar seating. Have a couple of board games lying around that you can play at your table as well. Counter service, and use trophies as table markers. Limited seating in the area where you order, but tons of seating in the tap room. Pizza is New York-style. Can either get an 18-inch pizza with your choice of toppings, or a $4/5 slice. Also have vegan and vegetarian options. Stay open super late (Midnight T-Th & 3:30 AM F &  Sat). My review should be taken with a grain of salt because I grew up outside of NY (and am therefore a pizza snob) but I tried both the sausage and the pepperoni and was not a huge fan of either. The crust was too crunchy and the pizza was too thin. It tasted like an STL pizzeria's take of a NY pizza to me. I tried a salad as well and it was ok, but not great

Review 2:

Overall, a solid place to grab NY-style pizza at the Grove. I have walked by Pie Guy a couple of times and was interested in trying it. I was able to go with a friend and we went to both Gezellig and Pie Guy at the same time. I got a slice of the cheese pizza and it was different that other slices that I've had in the city (Pizza Head, the URB etc.). There was a more definite herb flavor to the pizza than the places that I mentioned that resonated throughout eating my cheese slice. Pricing was around $4 for the cheese and around ~$5 for pizza with toppings, which is similar to the URB and Pizza Head. Another plus to Pie Guy is the location. It's connected to a great place to get beers for a reasonable price (Gezellig) and you can bring the beers from Gezellig over to Pie Guy to chow down on your pizza while drinking beer. The hours also make it a good place to grab a late night snack in the Grove.

Review 3:

I love this place!  Super friendly staff, interesting setup next to a bar ( where you can choose from a huge selection of beers).  A small amount of indoor seating is available as well as outdoor seating.  It's a great spot for people watching.  We ordered a cheese pizza and a Saint Louis Chopped salad.  The salad was great...very fresh and tasty.  The pizza was excellent.  We ordered an 18" Cheese.  It's NY style here.  The crust is special...crispy and light.   Next time I'm there I'll probably order extra sauce as it was lighter than I prefer. If you're not drinking alcohol from next door, there's water and free Koolaid.   All the cups & utensils and dishes are recyclable or compost ready.  Nice touch!

Wrap Up

Pie Guy Pizza is one of the many great pizza options available in St. Louis. The hand tossed New York style will satisfy any pizza craving you may have, and the best part is, you can order food delivery from Pie Guy Pizza here and get it delivered right to your door in St. Louis.