The Search for the Best Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh is Over

This list could have been so much longer considering how many amazing Italian restaurants there are in Pittsburgh But we had to stop it somewhere. Below is a comprehensive guide to the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh according to Google Reviews. If you’re looking for your next hearty Italian meal, use this list to find the perfect spot. From the classics to the contemporary, this list has it all.


Ratings and additional data pulled from Google:


Dish Osteria Bar

Alla Famiglia

Cucina Vitale

Gran Canal Caffè

Colangelo's

Joseph Tambellini Restaurant

Legends Eatery

Piazza Talarico and Papa Joe’s Wine Cellar

Piccolo Forno

DiAnoia's Eatery

Stagioni

Sarafino's Homestyle Italian

Mercurio's

Scoglio Greentree

DeLallo's Fort Couch Cafe

Pino's Contemporary Italian Restaurant

Senti Restaurant

Sienna Mercato

Piada Italian Street Food

Girasole

Bella Notte

La Tavola Italiana Restaurant

Vallozzi's Pittsburgh

Zarra's Restaurant

Alexanders Italian Bistro

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant


For more detailed information about the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh, see below:

Dish Osteria Bar

128 S 17th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203, United States

Quaint eatery & bar for pastas, seafood, wine, amaros & more Sicilian & Mediterranean dishes.

Late-night food · Comfort food · Small plates

4.9 Stars, 186 Reviews, $$$


Alla Famiglia

804 E Warrington Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15210, United States

Steaks, seafood & pasta in a refined atmosphere with an upstairs cocktail lounge & patio seating.

Comfort food · Great dessert · Upmarket

4.8 Stars, 521 Reviews, $$$$


Cucina Vitale

2516 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203, United States

Traditional Italian recipes plus BYOB & dessert in mellow, no-nonsense environs.

Cash only · Comfort food · Breakfast

4.8 Stars, 182 Reviews, $$


Gran Canal Caffè

1021 N Canal St, Pittsburgh, PA 15215, United States

Comfort food · Healthy options · Great dessert

4.8 Stars, 66 Reviews, Price n/a


Colangelo's

207 21st St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States

Small spot with sidewalk seating for classic & Italian baked goods, panini & other cafe fare.

Comfort food · Quick bite · Great dessert

4.8 Stars, 115 Reviews, Price n/a


Joseph Tambellini Restaurant

5701 Bryant St, Pittsburgh, PA 15206, United States

The chef-owner offers modern takes on classic Italian cuisine plus wines at this refined choice.

Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Healthy options

4.7 Stars, 258 Reviews, $$$


Legends Eatery

500 E North Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15212, United States

Quaint, family-friendly corner eatery for old-school Italian fare & American desserts with BYOB.

Reservations required · Comfort food · Small plates

4.7 Stars, 233 Reviews, $$


Piazza Talarico and Papa Joe’s Wine Cellar

3832 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15201, United States

Happy hour drinks · Comfort food · Outdoor seating

4.7 Stars, 76 Reviews, $$


Piccolo Forno

3801 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201, United States

Charming BYOB spot for handmade pasta, wood-fired pizza & tiramisu amid simple & classic decor.

Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Small plates

4.6 Stars, 584 Reviews, $$


DiAnoia's Eatery

2549 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States

Homey, all-day stop for housemade pastas & Italian dishes, plus pastries, coffee & cocktails.

Comfort food · Breakfast · Small plates

4.6 Stars, 1,062 Reviews, $$


Stagioni

2104 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203, United States

Italian eatery plates Tuscan favorites using local, seasonal ingredients in a warm, charming space.

Comfort food · Small plates · Great dessert

4.6 Stars, 176 Reviews, $$


Sarafino's Homestyle Italian

40 E Crafton Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15205, United States

Old-fashioned Italian-American restaurant with plentiful portions of pasta, pizza & panini.

Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Fast service

4.6 Stars, 500 Reviews, $$


Mercurio's

5523 Walnut St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, United States

This bright, family-owned Italian eatery is known for its homemade gelato & Neapolitan pizza.

Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Small plates

4.6 Stars, 692 Reviews, $$


Scoglio Greentree

Foster Plaza Building 7, 661 Andersen Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15220, United States

Pasta, seafood & other traditional Italian fare, plus wine, in a quaint, comfortable space.

Comfort food · Healthy options · Great dessert

4.6 Stars, 288 Reviews, $$


DeLallo's Fort Couch Cafe

91 Fort Couch Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15241, United States

Established outpost for homemade ravioli & other classic Italian dishes served in a relaxed setting.

Comfort food · Great dessert · Upmarket

4.5 Stars, 412 Reviews, $$


Pino's Contemporary Italian Restaurant

6738 Reynolds St, Pittsburgh, PA 15206, United States

This cozy, chef-owned spot with mosaic tabletops offers contemporary Italian cuisine & a wine list.

Comfort food · Small plates · Healthy options

4.5 Stars, 165 Reviews, $$


Senti Restaurant

3473 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201, United States

Art-filled Italian eatery offering fresh takes on classics & a wine bar with an automatic dispenser.

Happy hour food · Happy hour drinks · Comfort food

4.5 Stars, 238 Reviews, $$


Sienna Mercato

942 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States

A 2-story Italian eatery offering diverse dining options such as a rooftop beer garden & a pizzeria.

Happy hour food · Late-night food · Happy hour drinks

4.4 Stars, 2,329 Reviews, $$


Piada Italian Street Food

3600 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, United States

Counter-order chain serving design-your-own Italian food including wraps, pastas & salads.

Comfort food · Quick bite · Healthy options

4.4 Stars, 991 Reviews, $


Girasole

733 Copeland St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, United States

Contemporary, seasonal updates of rustic Italian dishes served in a setting with stone walls.

Comfort food · Outdoor seating · Great dessert

4.4 Stars, 539 Reviews, $$


Bella Notte

1914 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States

Booths line the walls of this relaxed Italian restaurant with an Italian flag–colored ceiling.

Happy hour food · Comfort food · Outdoor seating

4.4 Stars, 801 Reviews, $


La Tavola Italiana Restaurant

1 Boggs Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15211, United States

Long-running, family-owned BYOB Italian eatery offering Sicilian specialties, pizza & hoagies.

Comfort food · Great dessert · Cosy

4.4 Stars, 237 Reviews, $$


Vallozzi's Pittsburgh

220 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States

Imaginative Italian fare including meat & pasta plus an extensive wine list in a sophisticated room.

Happy hour food · Comfort food · Small plates

4.3 Stars, 341 Reviews, $$$


Zarra's Restaurant

3887 Bigelow Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, United States

Easygoing restaurant serving classic Italian eats such as pasta & seafood dishes.

Comfort food · Cosy · Romantic

4.2 Stars, 156 Reviews, $$


Alexanders Italian Bistro

5104 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224, United States

Traditional Italian spot with red-sauce entrees & a customizable pasta option, plus sidewalk tables.

Happy hour food · Happy hour drinks · Comfort food

4.1 Stars, 327 Reviews, $$


Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

3 E Station Square Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15219, United States

Chain serving family-style Italian fare in a kitschy setting featuring red-&-white tablecloths.

Late-night food · Comfort food · Cosy

4.0 Stars, 720 Reviews, $$




As you’ll see, there are lots of great options to find the meal you’re looking for. If you don’t feel like eating out, and would rather stay at home, remember you can still get all these great meals in the comfort of your house with food delivery.

With FoodBoss, you can easily find the best food delivery option by comparing multiple food delivery services at once. Compare various delivery fees, service fees, small cart fees, and other fees as well as varying delivery estimate times. Never overpay or wait too long for food delivery ever again.

The most restaurants, the quickest delivery times, the cheapest delivery fees. Every time.